I'm not going to get into, much, what is known of the gory details, Jon. In a nutshell, in November of 1990 you would have been a sophomore at The University of Texas at Austin. You were in the Sigma Nu fraternity. I guess if they had a house, you would've lived in it. So, you're a brother and I'm sure it was Hell Week that November or whatever they called it; when "pledges" are put through their paces before they can "get in." Different frats have different traditions and rituals. One of the common ones is "the pledge paddle." My husband still has his. He had to get all the signatures of the older brothers. They didn't make it easy. They put the guys through all kinds of shit to get the signatures. Paddle signatures are pretty innocuous; but the paddle itself is not. It's a hefty plank of wood with a handle.
And what did you do with your Sigma Nu paddle? Well ALLEGEDLY you hit a pledge with it so hard he nearly lost a kidney.
Yes, we have to say ALLEGEDLY about all of this because as I mentioned, the hard facts of all of it seem to be rather soft. This is what I know:
A pledge named Mark Allen Sanders accused you, Jon Hamm and several other Sigma Nu brothers of a hazing so severe his spine was fractured, his kidney injured and his pants were set on fire and he had to "blow out" the flames with his breath. ALLEGEDLY, much of this; particularly at your hands, Jon Hamm, (allegedly). In particular the paddle incident and some creative use of a hammer that seemed to go above and beyond the usual threshold of cruel and unusual frat hijinks. It seems that you and the other brothers were demanding Mark Sanders to recount your various and sundry nick-names which is certainly a feasible fraternity shenanigan. When he couldn't remember yours in particular, Jon; you ALLEGEDLY claimed one of your nicknames was "M.C. Hammer" (I think I can guess...) and when he couldn't remember it; you ALLEGEDLY grew extremely angry and then produced a hammer from your sleeve, hooked the claw behind his scrotum (he was wearing jeans, thankfully) and led him around the room by it. Did you premed--err--pre-plan this or did the hammer just happen to be in the room--allegedly?
This is really interesting to me. I really just learned about all of this. And then the other day, this commercial aired:
Okay, I get it. Young boys whose skulls haven't fused yet. Alcohol bringing about heretofore unknown personality changes. Peer pressure. Pressure cooker atmosphere. Young men willing to do ANYTHING to belong. Things get out of hand. Yes, I get it. Shit happens; especially in this truly toxic all-male, cult-like atmosphere. But here's what I really don't get, Jon. Your response to this when you were finally asked about it in a public forum (that being an Esquire magazine interview) was the following (and this is directly from that article*):
A bummer?
"...a bummer of a thing that happened."
Exactly who was it a bummer for?
I mean, it seems like it was a bummer for you Jon. Certainly not Mark Allen, who it seems is lucky to have gotten out of that situation with his life. And not merely a bummer for your frat bros, who did jail-time (this is, I believe, an undisputed fact).
I guess those quotes from Esquire are your only and official response to this subject. And it's quite the dismissal. Among the problems I have with it is...well...all of it, really. First, you say it was a "big situation." But it wasn't. It was a very small situation. One house...I'm guessing maybe around twenty to thirty guys? A situation in a frat house couldn't be smaller or more intimate. You say it was all "sensationalized." Jon, it shut down a frat house. People went to jail. It seems to me that it was minimalized, if anything. You are so quick to say that you were acquitted and not convicted. Some might see this as worming out of it with barely a slap on the wrist. How quick you were, Jon, to absolve yourself of any guilt or responsibility. And that instant refusal to take any responsibility; or accountability or any kind of blame makes me fear something. It makes me fear that you might be a narcissist Jon. Because in my experience with narcissists (and I've had more than my fair share) the common thread amongst all of them was the absolute refusal to ever accept blame for something. To admit responsibility. To acknowledge fault. I would post a NARCISSIST CHECKLIST for you but it would be pointless. Narcissists seem to be incurable and even if they realize they have a problem, they don't care. It's actually quite sad. And I hope it's not true for you. And if it isn't, then you have a choice to own up to these past actions, accept responsibility and enact some kind of atonement or reparations. Perhaps a PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT about the dangers of HAZING. Do you know how much good that could do, coming from you? It could actually save lives.
Here's one of the accompanying fashion photos from the Esquire article:
Oh, so it's lemonade. Perhaps there is a glimmer of hope in all of this Jon. Lemons are loaded with not just vitamin C, but all kinds of symbolism.
And I promised I was going to say some nice things about you Jon...so here we go.
During the height of Mad Men Mania, Banana Republic did a tie-in with the show:
But the contest itself was something of a sham. These incredibly creative photos, by not just me but a lot of fans of the show, were not assessed creatively. The winner was not picked due to artistic merit. No. It became clear that some people had their photos submitting over and over again by some kind of algorithm. The man who won the contest wasn't even done up in Mad Men style. It was a joke, really.
Also, Jon, one of my most favorite dramatic scenes from any filmed media was from Mad Men and you were in the scene. It was the time you took your young wife to Howard Johnson's, so sure she would love the orange sherbet. Let's take a look:
I can't find the exact moment in the scene; but we can see some of it here...
So there we are. It seems we are at some kind of crossroads. Well, at least I am. Did you ever do anything with your English degree Jon? Do you write? Perhaps you could write an article about that night in November of 1990. An apologia of sorts. An examination of something you, at least, never seem to have examined. I bet People magazine would publish it. They love that stuff. I can see the copy on the cover now: Jon Hamm Wants to Tell You Something; or something along those lines. I think you kind of owe it to everyone who has supported you in your career. And maybe you have apologized to Mark Allen Sanders; but I don't think it would hurt to put it in writing for all of us to see.
MARK "L." WALBERG, self-proclaimed bringer together of loving couples, went on to host another game show called The Moment of Truth:
MEGYN KELLY
Miss Kelly continues to flip-flop her politics according to what's most advantageous for herself; put her nose where it doesn't belong in the lives of celebrity women she seems to be jealous of and run her big fat mouth ad-nauseum while sporting a hairdo she's way too old for. I call it "The Playboy Mansion '97." As in: "Hey Megyn...Crystal Hefner called from 1997...she wants her hair back." And some call it sad. (CAT HISS SFX).
After being acquitted in the death of Don Draper, Peggy left her advertising life behind and became a nun.
Nobody knows. They won two hundred dollars for their date, which is worth about twice that today, in 2026. Were foot massages traded? Were pedicures purchased? Where did they go for their date? Why didn't that cheap-ass show pay for their date and let them keep the extra cash? Like, how about dinner at L'Orangerie? Or Lawry's Prime Rib, home of the world famous Spinning Salad? That would have been a fun date!
ADDENDUM FORTHCOMING
And now, a final word from our sponsor, FAB detergent with Lemon Freshened Borax, which somehow seems appropriate...